Leadership & Personal Development
Have a Constructive Conversation With a Non-Starter
The coach can protect competitive selection authority while giving the athlete accurate, specific information about development opportunities.
By Philip Coffman · Founder, iBE Performance ·
Team scenario · About 60 seconds
The room goes quiet
Pressure is rising. Your group has stopped talking, and people are guessing instead of communicating.
A practice exercise, not an assessment or diagnosis. Read the full guide below.
A capable athlete asks why they are not starting and receives a vague answer that leaves them feeling powerless.
The coach can protect competitive selection authority while giving the athlete accurate, specific information about development opportunities.
My approach is to make the next behavior visible, rehearse it in the environment where it matters, and review what actually happened. The goal is a usable response, not a promise to remove pressure.
Find the specific pressure point
Before changing a routine, write down one recent event: what happened, what you noticed, what you did next, and the part you could control. Do not label an entire person or team from one moment.
In this situation, focus on this distinction: The coach can protect competitive selection authority while giving the athlete accurate, specific information about development opportunities.
The IBE practice — four actions
Run this as a short, deliberate practice. Rehearse the steps in ordinary conditions before testing them during a difficult moment. Make each action observable.
- 1. Prepare the current role expectation and the observable criteria relevant to selection.
- 2. Invite the athlete's understanding of their assignment and clarify any mismatch without making promises.
- 3. Identify one or two trainable behaviors and where those behaviors will be evaluated.
- 4. Set a reasonable follow-up discussion and explain that performance progress does not guarantee a starting role.
Worked example
A midfielder learns that defensive recovery decisions are a priority for earning more minutes. The coach identifies the practice sequence that will show improvement and reviews footage with the player.
Rehearse the example once with the actual language and pace of your setting. A supervisor, coach, director, or teammate can give feedback about the behavior without making judgments about character.
What to record over the next week
Check whether the athlete can name the development target and whether the coach provides the agreed feedback. Do not turn minutes into a promised reward.
Record the number of opportunities alongside the number of completed responses. If no relevant situation occurs, leave that entry blank; do not call it a success or failure. Review whether the method is practical and adjust one step at a time.
Common mistake — and the correction
Do not expose teammates' private evaluations to defend a selection decision. Follow school or club participation policies.
Keep the standard specific enough that someone else could observe it. Avoid outcome guarantees, forced positivity, emotional suppression, or treating a person’s reaction as a clinical diagnosis.
Evidence and boundaries
Goal-setting research supports the value of clear, challenging, appropriately supported objectives. Track process behavior alongside outcomes rather than treating one target as a complete measure of performance.
Performance training. Not therapy. This educational exercise is not a diagnosis, a clinical assessment, or a substitute for medical, mental-health, safeguarding, human-resources, or emergency procedures.
The four-action sequence and tracking prompts here are original IBE coaching applications. The cited research informs the general principle; it does not validate this particular protocol or establish a guaranteed timeline.
Train the next response
Choose one situation this week, use the four actions, and write down the next controllable adjustment. If you want help adapting the routine to your actual role or team, I can talk through it with you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Mental Performance Coaching FAQ
How long should I use this leadership & personal development practice?
Use it for a handful of realistic opportunities, then review actual behavior. There is no scientifically guaranteed number of repetitions for this IBE exercise.
What if it does not help?
Change the cue or simplify the next action. If distress, health, safety, or functioning is a concern, seek the appropriate qualified support rather than relying on a performance worksheet.
Turn This Guide Into a Practical Plan
Build a response for your actual performance environment.
Use the practical tools in this guide to identify a trainable response. A structured scorecard or a focused conversation can help clarify your next step; neither is a prerequisite for the other.
